JJ&SW Labs

Tag: Returns policies

  • How to Get a Refund from a Closed Online Shop

    The short answer

    If an online shop has closed, first establish why it closed and how you paid. The practical route may be to:

    1. Preserve your order, payment, correspondence and closure records.
    2. Check whether the business is simply closed, still in administration, in liquidation or subject to bankruptcy proceedings.
    3. Contact the trader or the identified administrator or liquidator where appropriate.
    4. Contact your card provider or PayPal promptly to ask whether a dispute or other recovery route may apply.
    5. Register as a creditor if an applicable insolvency process requires it.

    This guidance is UK-focused, with some payment guidance specifically focused on England. Section 75, chargeback and PayPal disputes are conditional routes, not guaranteed refunds. The result depends on the business’s legal status, your payment method and the facts of the transaction.

    Separate the three questions

    A closed shop creates three different issues that should not be treated as one:

    1. Did the seller owe you a refund?

    Under UK consumer law, an online seller may have refund obligations for matters such as goods that are faulty or not as described, or a valid cancellation of a distance purchase. The rules have conditions and exceptions. For example, some online purchases have a 14-day cancellation period, but exclusions can apply to certain types of goods or services. Fault-related rights and statutory claim periods also have their own conditions.

    Those rights describe what the seller may owe. They do not, by themselves, guarantee that you can recover the money after the seller has stopped trading.

    2. What happened to the business?

    “Closed” can mean several different things:

    • Temporarily or ordinarily closed: the business may still have a working owner, customer-service channel or replacement contact.
    • In administration: an administrator may be handling the business, and the shop may still be able to fulfil orders or deal with claims.
    • In liquidation: the company’s assets are being dealt with as part of a winding-up process. You may need to identify the liquidator and register a creditor claim.
    • Bankruptcy or compulsory liquidation: the formal creditor process and available remedies depend on the specific insolvency case.

    Administration, liquidation, bankruptcy and ordinary closure are not interchangeable. Check the business website, official insolvency information, recent correspondence and any notice naming an administrator, liquidator or other insolvency contact. If an insolvency process is identified, follow the relevant official creditor-claim instructions rather than assuming that contacting the former shop will be enough.

    3. Which payment route might be available?

    Your payment method can materially change the next step. A possible card or PayPal route is separate from an insolvency claim, so the existence of an insolvency process does not automatically mean you should stop asking your provider whether a dispute route is available.

    Step-by-step recovery process

    Step 1: Gather the evidence

    Keep copies of material relevant to the route you may pursue, including:

    • the order confirmation and description of the goods or service;
    • proof of payment and the payment method used;
    • delivery, cancellation, return or fault correspondence;
    • messages to or from the shop;
    • evidence that the website or business has closed; and
    • any notice identifying an administrator, liquidator or insolvency process.

    Payment providers may ask for supporting evidence. Keeping a clear record also helps if you need to explain what was purchased, what went wrong and what contact you attempted.

    Step 2: Contact the trader where that is still practical

    If the business still has a functioning contact route, ask for the refund or an explanation of the order’s status. This is not a guarantee that the shop will respond, but some payment-provider processes expect you to try the trader first.

    If an administrator or liquidator is identified, use the published contact or creditor-claim route instead of treating the former customer-service address as the only option. Follow the instructions for that particular insolvency case.

    Step 3: Contact the payment provider

    Ask the provider which current dispute or recovery process may fit the facts. Explain that the seller has closed or entered an identified insolvency process, and provide the transaction and contact records requested.

    #### Credit card or eligible BNPL payment

    In England, Citizens Advice explains that Section 75 may generally apply to qualifying credit-card or buy-now-pay-later purchases costing more than £100 and up to £30,000 per item. Eligibility can depend on the transaction structure and other facts, so these figures should not be treated as a universal guarantee or as rules for every jurisdiction.

    A payment made through a third party or split across payment methods can affect the analysis. Ask the provider to assess the actual transaction rather than assuming that any credit-card or BNPL payment qualifies.

    #### Debit card or charge card

    A chargeback may be available in some circumstances, including situations that do not fall within Section 75. It is not the same as a guaranteed refund, and the provider must assess the transaction under its applicable process. Contact the relevant card provider through its documented dispute channel and verify current eligibility and timing directly with it.

    #### PayPal

    PayPal may have a dispute route for some transactions. England-focused Citizens Advice guidance identifies a 180-day PayPal dispute period, but this is not a universal rule for every transaction or jurisdiction. Check the current PayPal terms and the status of the particular payment promptly.

    #### Barclaycard payments

    For a payment made wholly or partly with a Barclaycard, Barclaycard’s own guidance describes a route that starts with contacting the retailer and then submitting a dispute if the payment cannot be fulfilled. Its instructions identify online or app-based claim steps and supporting evidence.

    Those are Barclaycard-specific instructions. Do not assume that another card issuer uses the same interface, process or eligibility rules. Contact your own provider and follow its current documented procedure. Submitting documents does not guarantee a provisional or final refund.

    Step 4: Consider the insolvency-creditor route

    If the business is in an identified insolvency process, find the relevant administrator, liquidator or official creditor-claim process and register the money owed where the process requires it.

    For bankruptcy and compulsory liquidation, UK government guidance explains that recovery depends on the circumstances of the insolvency and the assets available. Distributions follow statutory priority. An unsecured creditor may receive little or nothing. That warning applies to the relevant insolvency context; it does not mean that every closed online shop has no prospect of paying customers.

    Being listed as a creditor does not guarantee payment. It is a way of putting the claim into the applicable process, not a promise of recovery.

    What if you had an ordinary UK refund right?

    Do not discard ordinary consumer-law information merely because the shop has closed. In the UK, online cancellation, faulty-goods and not-as-described rules may still help establish what the seller owed. However, the rules contain exceptions and are not the same thing as a bank dispute or insolvency claim.

    For example:

    • online cancellation rights can have a 14-day period and exceptions;
    • refund obligations can differ depending on whether the issue is cancellation, non-delivery, a fault or a mismatch with the description;
    • fault-related rules can involve a six-month period; and
    • statutory claim periods can be six years, or five years in some parts of the UK.

    These are UK consumer-law details, not universal payment-dispute deadlines and not general deadlines for every insolvency claim. Check the rule applicable to your location, purchase and claim before relying on a period.

    If the shop simply stopped responding

    Treat non-response as a fact to document, not as proof of a particular legal status. Save messages, delivery information and evidence of the failed contact attempt. Then check whether there is an identified insolvency process and ask your payment provider whether its dispute route may apply.

    Do not assume that a former website’s disappearance means there is an administrator, or that a card provider must accept the claim. Conversely, do not assume that an insolvency process eliminates every possible payment-provider route.

    Bottom line

    The safest decision path is:

    1. Document the transaction and closure.
    2. Identify the business status: ordinary closure, administration, liquidation or bankruptcy-related process.
    3. Contact the trader or the relevant insolvency representative where appropriate.
    4. Ask the card provider or PayPal about a conditional dispute or recovery route.
    5. Register as an unsecured creditor if the applicable insolvency process calls for it.
    6. Verify current eligibility and timing with the relevant provider or official process.

    A seller’s underlying refund obligation, a payment-provider dispute and an insolvency claim are separate matters. None guarantees that the money will be returned, and the available result may differ outside the UK or England-focused guidance described here.

    Sources and further reading

  • Marks and Spencer returns policy: 28-day standard window and Sale exceptions

    Marks and Spencer returns policy

    For M&S Ireland, the standard returns policy is 28 days for both online and in-store purchases. However, online Sale items have a separate 14-day rule, and some purchases have additional exclusions or restrictions on where and how they can be returned.

    Standard M&S return period

    The official M&S Ireland returns information states that the standard return period is 28 days for:

    • Online purchases
    • In-store purchases

    The page also describes both in-store and postal return routes. The appropriate route may depend on how the item was purchased and the type of product involved.

    Online Sale items

    Online Sale items do not necessarily follow the standard 28-day policy. M&S states that they have a 14-day return limit, together with associated notification and return periods.

    If you are returning an online Sale item, check the applicable dates and instructions on the M&S returns page rather than assuming that the standard 28-day period applies.

    Other restrictions to check

    The policy information also indicates that:

    • Sale items may be subject to different limits and exclusions.
    • Certain Sale, clothing and homeware purchases may have restrictions on the available return location or method.
    • Outlet purchases may also be subject to return-location or return-method restrictions.
    • Returns generally need to be made within the dates stated by M&S.
    • Items must meet M&S’s original-condition requirements, but the available policy excerpt does not show the full list of conditions and exclusions.

    These details mean that the 28-day rule is a useful starting point, not a guarantee that every item can be returned in the same way.

    Before returning an item

    1. Confirm whether the purchase was made online or in a store.
    2. Check whether it was a Sale or Outlet purchase.
    3. Confirm the relevant deadline, particularly for an online Sale item.
    4. Check whether the product category has a specified return location or method.
    5. Review the current M&S instructions for the complete condition and exclusion requirements.

    Jurisdiction note

    The information summarised here comes from M&S’s official Ireland returns page. Returns rules can vary by country, so customers outside Ireland should use the M&S returns information for their own market. The page does not display a clear publication or update date, so check the current official instructions before sending an item back.

    Sources and further reading